MARIES COUNTY — Former Maries County deputy Jay Yelton says harassment over his transgender status, reductions in his work hours and unequal treatment preceded his dismissal following an …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
We have recently launched a new and improved website. To continue reading, you will need to either log into your member account, or purchase a new membership.
If you are a current print subscriber, you can set up a free website account by clicking here.
Otherwise, click here to view your options for becoming a member.
Please log in to continue |
|
MARIES COUNTY — Former Maries County deputy Jay Yelton says harassment over his transgender status, reductions in his work hours and unequal treatment preceded his dismissal following an investigation into $5,300 in missing cash evidence.
In an Oct. 12 interview with The Maries County Advocate, Yelton discussed the allegations behind his federal discrimination and retaliation case against the Maries County Sheriff’s Department. He also described concerns about the treatment of residents and said he is considering starting a support group for people in rural communities facing similar experiences.
Yelton said his interest in pursuing the case extends beyond his former job or financial recovery.
Missing cash and dismissal
Yelton’s complaint states that he seized $5,300 during a June 5, 2025, arrest and logged and reported the evidence according to department procedures. The money subsequently disappeared from department custody.
During the interview, Yelton said he was both the arresting officer and the person who reported the missing money.
“I was the arresting officer on that case,” he said. “I was also the one that reported the evidence missing.”
He disputed a department Facebook post that he said credited an evidence custodian or technician with reporting the loss. Yelton said he reported it through his chain of command.
According to Yelton, the written explanation for his dismissal cited a failure to make a report connected to the underlying case. He disputed that explanation, saying a child involved had been sent to Florida that same day and that he had been told there was no need to make the report.
Yelton described the arrest as his first drug arrest after leaving the academy. He said he received approximately two weeks of field training before being assigned to patrol on his own, without having made an independent arrest under field-training supervision.
He also said he recorded his termination meeting with Sheriff Mark Morgan. According to Yelton, Morgan told him the dismissal ultimately came down to the missing money because the department “took a lot of heat over it.”
Yelton said Morgan dismissed him on a day scheduled for department photographs. He said several people told him they believed Morgan did not want him included in the photographs because he is transgender, and Yelton said he shared that belief.
He did not identify those people during the interview.
Yelton also alleged that two officers acknowledged failing polygraph examinations connected to the missing cash investigation and continued working in law enforcement. He said he recorded their statements.
Harassment complaints
Yelton identified Deputy John Durban as the person who told him he needed his testosterone adjusted because his estrogen was showing. According to Yelton, Durban acknowledged making the comment in a letter.
Yelton said another deputy expressed an interest in seeing his genitals because they were different. He did not identify that deputy during the interview.
Yelton acknowledged making jokes about his own body, but said that did not make the other comments acceptable and that they crossed boundaries.
He also said he learned of disparaging comments questioning why someone would be attracted to him. Yelton said he reported some of the conduct to his sergeant, including through text messages.
He also described waiting approximately two hours for an investigative interview while concerned about a medical appointment involving his mother.
Yelton recalled telling Durban he wished the interview would begin because he had “bigger fish to fry,” referring to his mother’s appointment.
According to Yelton, Durban responded, “Obviously, you don’t. You’re here.”
Reduced hours and a policy dispute
Yelton said he was required to shorten his shifts and use compensatory time he had earned working overtime and responding to calls.
“I was forced to take three hours off of every shift that I worked,” he said.
He recalled the reductions beginning in July or August of 2025, although he could not provide a precise date.
Yelton said the requirement depleted time he wanted to save to care for his mother following major surgery. He said he asked to preserve the time and was told he would accumulate enough before the surgery, but his calculations showed otherwise.
He disputed being told other deputies were also reducing their hours, saying their use of leave was voluntary while his was required.
Yelton also disputed the characterization that he refused to comply with a shaving requirement. He said he asked to see the grooming policy and was never provided a copy.
“It wasn’t that I was being defiant,” he said.
Complaints about other deputies
Yelton questioned whether the department applied discipline consistently, identifying two deputies whose conduct he said he reported.
He identified Deputy Ryan Ervin as the deputy involved in an earlier evidence-handling complaint. Yelton alleged he was instructed to discard a trash bag that contained case evidence and recovered stolen property that had not been logged.
Yelton said he reported the matter to former Chief Deputy Scott John and that Ervin received a 30-day suspension without pay. He identified John and former Sheriff Chris Heitman as people who could corroborate the circumstances.
Yelton alleged Ervin received more favorable treatment after Morgan took office and said he had been told Ervin received back pay. The interview did not clearly establish what formal action, if any, changed the earlier discipline.
Yelton identified Justin Fletcher as another deputy he reported, alleging Fletcher claimed to have checked a call while remaining at the Vienna fairgrounds. He also alleged a dispatcher helped support the account that Fletcher had responded.
He said vehicle-location records could help establish whether Fletcher left the fairgrounds. The disciplinary records, dispatch communications and vehicle-location information were not included with the interview materials.
Yelton said Fletcher received a suspension and argued that the outcome differed from his own dismissal.
Route HH search and separate lawsuit
Yelton also discussed a separate search on Route HH involving allegations of evidence planting concerning Morgan and Ervin.
Yelton described his role in the operation, saying he helped clear the house as a member of the entry team before conducting enforcement activity outside. He said he was arresting two people in the driveway and searching a vehicle during the period under discussion.
Yelton expressly said he did not know what occurred inside the house concerning the alleged evidence planting.
A separate federal civil rights lawsuit, Fritchey v. Maries County Sheriff’s Office, was filed Sept. 28 in the Eastern District of Missouri. The docket listing identifies Duane A. Fritchey and Nicholas Pappas as plaintiffs and names the sheriff, Morgan, the Maries County Commission, Fletcher, Yelton and Ervin as defendants.
The docket listing reviewed establishes the existence of that lawsuit but does not describe the underlying search. The complaint has not been reviewed to independently establish its connection to the Route HH operation discussed in the interview.
Comment after dismissal
Yelton said he continued volunteering in the community after losing his job, including at a sheriff’s posse fundraiser benefiting the junior deputy program.
After the event, he said, an anonymous Facebook account posted a comment questioning his participation because he is transgender and making a claim about his personal relationship that he disputed.
Yelton said he saved a screenshot and provided it to his lawyer.
He identified former officer Erican Sugg as having attended the event and said Sugg was the only person there who knew the personal information at issue. Yelton said the comment appeared approximately 30 minutes after the event ended.
Yelton connected those circumstances to his suspicion about Sugg, but there is no supplied evidence independently establishing who wrote the comment or controlled the account.
Yelton said he did not approach or confront the officer at the event.
“It definitely hurt me,” he said of the comment.
Concerns for residents
Yelton said he believes he experienced prejudice because he is transgender and questioned what that could mean for other residents who depend on law enforcement.
He contrasted his dismissal with the suspensions he said other deputies received, arguing that he was not given the same opportunity as the rest of his male colleagues.
Yelton described law enforcement as a childhood ambition and said the experience damaged his career.
“To feel that it was taken from me by somebody who is afraid of someone who’s different, it doesn’t feel fair,” he said.
He said the workplace treatment affected his sleep and left him feeling unsupported by fellow officers.
“I felt alone before even being alone,” he said.
Discussing the comments he attributed to Durban, Yelton questioned how members of the public might be treated.
“These comments were being made to a brother who wears the badge,” he said. “I can only imagine what’s being said about the citizens.”
Yelton said his experience could leave residents concerned about whether their rights would be respected.
“They don’t deserve their rights to be violated,” he said.
Proposed rural support group
Yelton said he wants to help people in rural communities experiencing similar treatment and would welcome them reaching out to him.
“I’m honestly thinking about starting a support group for people in rural areas that are going through stuff like this,” he said.
He said he wants people to know resources are available and that others have experienced similar struggles. The proposed group remained an idea at the time of the interview.
Asked about transgender residents and people still figuring out who they are, Yelton encouraged them to continue pursuing their lives and goals despite others’ opinions.
“Don’t give up on being who you are because of somebody else’s opinion,” he said.
Yelton said he continues to pursue a career in law enforcement.
Raymon Lampert of Lampert Law Office, LLC, Yelton’s attorney, was participating in the interview and described Yelton’s federal case as being in its early stages at that time. The attorney encouraged people with firsthand knowledge of relevant conversations or conduct, including former employees, to contact his office to discuss information privately.
Yelton said his interest in pursuing the case extends beyond financial recovery.
“I want to protect the citizens that I don’t serve anymore,” he said.