BELLE — Aldermen unanimously postponed a proposed commercial rezoning on Lehnoff Drive Nov. 10 following a lengthy debate over neighboring residents’ health concerns, dust control and whether a …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
We have recently launched a new and improved website. To continue reading, you will need to either log into your member account, or purchase a new membership.
If you are a current print subscriber, you can set up a free website account by clicking here.
Otherwise, click here to view your options for becoming a member.
Please log in to continue |
|
BELLE — Aldermen unanimously postponed a proposed commercial rezoning on Lehnoff Drive Nov. 10 following a lengthy debate over neighboring residents’ health concerns, dust control and whether a developer’s commitments were adequately documented.
Tony Gieck is seeking to rezone five acres from agricultural to commercial for storage units. The city’s Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval, but the aldermen delayed action until December to allow time for written commitments and review of a letter raising health and civil rights concerns.
The discussion grew heated as Gieck expressed frustration with the process and residents challenged how the development would affect their neighborhood.
“There is a rule on Ag 1 (a zoning classification) that nobody here can stop because it’s in your ordinances. I promise you. If they think the storage unit is bad, wait till the next thing I put in,” Gieck said while arguing that other uses were possible under the property’s agricultural zoning.
“Is that a threat?” asked Alderman Rebecca Withouse.
“It’s a promise,” Gieck said. “We don’t have to ask your permission for anything, so not a threat.”
Moments later, Gieck added, “I mean, there’s a lot worse that can go in.”
Mayor James (Pudd) Mitchell then asked them to calm down.
During public comments earlier in the meeting, neighboring resident Paulette Fricke said the proposed development would change the surroundings of her home. She raised concerns about storage units behind her property, additional traffic and potential effects on property values.
“This rezoning is going to change the atmosphere around my house. This is going to lower my property value,” Fricke said.
Fricke accused the board of favoring Gieck over neighboring residents.
“The neighborhood I moved into has changed because of all of you, and you’re going to change it more for one person, and this is favoritism,” she said.
Gieck urged aldermen to follow the planning and zoning recommendation, pointing out that the city appointed the commission to evaluate such requests.
“You guys put them in that position to make the best choices that you thought they could,” he said.
Mitchell also disclosed that the city had received a letter concerning the proposed development’s potential effect on a neighboring resident’s health. Reading from the letter, he said its author reported filing a civil rights complaint with the U.S. Department of Justice and another advocacy organization.
Mitchell said the concern centered on whether additional dust would create health problems for the resident. He said the city would research the matter and follow up with the person who submitted the letter.
“We have another person that wrote a letter, and they didn’t want to come forth tonight. So I’m not going to read the letter in full. It got to do with the zoning and planning and zoning situation,” said Mitchell. “We don’t feel that it should be read in full until we have a chance to do some research on it. I want everyone to know we did receive a letter. We’re not hiding it at all. So, that’s about all we have to say about that one.”
Alderwoman Rebecca Withouse asked that board members receive copies before deciding the rezoning request. The city attorney, James Klahr, agreed that aldermen should have an opportunity to read it.
When the board reached the rezoning item, Withouse said residents had contacted her with objections. She also raised questions about the status of Lehnoff Drive and said she wanted the attorney to examine the letter before the board acted.
Withouse asked Gieck to put proposed accommodations in writing, referring to screening and other measures discussed during the planning and zoning hearing. She said written commitments could prevent future disputes over what had been promised.
Gieck said engineering would be part of the development process, but he did not want to incur that expense before knowing whether the rezoning would be approved.
“I’m not going to put out the money for an engineer if I’m not going to get the zoning,” he said.
He said he had already paid for a survey and the zoning process and described development as a step-by-step undertaking. He also argued that agricultural activity on the property produces dust.
Board members and attendees discussed possible ways to control dust, including paving, treating the surface and using different types of rock. One participant argued that detailed construction requirements should be addressed before a building permit was issued, after the zoning decision.
Withouse proposed postponing the request until the following month so Gieck could provide a written plan addressing concerns and the attorney could review the letter.
“I think this has been discussed ever since May,” Gieck responded.
Withouse said she was not prepared to approve the request that evening.
“My decision right now would be no, based on what the citizens have told me,” she said. “Yes, we need businesses. Yes, but we also need families here as well to use those businesses. It is a fine line.”
Alderman Jeanette Struemph argued that the process had continued long enough and defended Gieck’s reluctance to pay for engineering before receiving a zoning decision.
Withouse said she understood Gieck’s desire for clarity but wanted a record that future boards could consult.
“I want it in writing. I want it official,” she said. “But I am not going to ignore citizen concerns, and I don’t think it’s wrong for you to want clarity and for us to want clarity.”
The discussion then revealed that some proposed measures were already recorded in planning and zoning hearing minutes that had not initially been provided to aldermen.
The city attorney distinguished between minutes documenting the commission’s meeting and those recording the hearing. A city staff member said the hearing minutes included a barrier, security cameras, fencing and measures intended to minimize disruption to the neighborhood.
Withouse said she had not received hearing minutes containing those details. Another board member also said the information was new to them.
Copies were provided during a recess.
The board had taken an initial voice vote on postponement before the discussion about the minutes. After the recess, Mitchell conducted a roll-call vote, and all four aldermen voted to table the request until December.
The board’s next regular meeting is scheduled for 6:30 p.m., Dec. 8 at the Lonnie Feeler Memorial Building.