BELLE — Alderman Steve Vogt said during the Aug. 26 board meeting that he would no longer respond to questions from The Maries County Advocate, describing the newspaper’s inquiries as a …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
We have recently launched a new and improved website. To continue reading, you will need to either log into your member account, or purchase a new membership.
If you are a current print subscriber, you can set up a free website account by clicking here.
Otherwise, click here to view your options for becoming a member.
Please log in to continue |
|
BELLE — Alderman Steve Vogt said during the Aug. 26 board meeting that he would no longer respond to questions from The Maries County Advocate, describing the newspaper’s inquiries as a “continuous, unending onslaught of unwarranted, insidious questions.”
Vogt’s statement came after The Advocate submitted 20 questions to Mayor James (Pudd) Mitchell and members of the Belle Board of Aldermen concerning the city’s relationship with Lauber Municipal Law, its handling of Missouri’s Sunshine Law and the increase in the city’s legal expenses.
The questions followed an Aug. 19 article published in The Advocate, written by staff from the Columbia Missourian. The Missourian’s investigation, originally published Aug. 12, examined Lauber Municipal Law’s work in small Missouri communities, including Belle, and raised questions concerning Sunshine Law compliance, access to public records, legal expenses and the firm’s influence on municipal operations.
During the Aug. 26 meeting, Vogt read a prepared statement responding to the newspaper’s questions.
“I will not be answering now or in the future a continuous, unending onslaught of unwarranted, insidious questions posed under the guise of transparency. There is nothing illegal or nefarious to see. Period. Citizens should be asking what the motivation or agenda is behind all the constant efforts to destroy and undermine the progress of the city of Belle has made and continues to make. I have served the city as an officeholder for over 40 years. When the city is successful, it’s because we, as elected officials, are working together. That does not mean we will always agree with each other, but when we have disagreements, we can and should discuss those during our regular meetings and before the citizens we serve, rather than using any third party, including the media, to serve as a substitute. That’s all I have,” Vogt said.
The questions submitted by The Advocate did not ask aldermen to resolve disagreements through the newspaper. Instead, they sought individual responses from elected officials concerning their oversight of city legal services, public-records practices, legal spending and the decisions made by the board of aldermen.
The questions were sent in an email to City Clerk Cindy Barbarick on Aug. 20, with a request that they be forwarded to Mitchell and each alderman. The email also offered elected officials the opportunity to participate in individual interviews or respond to the questions in writing. The full email sent by The Advocate follows:
“Cindy,
I have questions that need to be forwarded to Pudd and the aldermen concerning an article that was published in the Columbia Missourian on Aug. 12 dealing with Lauber Municipal Law that was picked up and ran by The Advocate.
On Aug. 19, The Maries County Advocate published an article from the Columbia Missourian that ran on Aug. 12 examining Lauber Municipal Law and the firm’s role in small communities across Missouri, including Belle. The article looked at the firm’s involvement in Sunshine Law matters, its influence on municipal decision-making and the increased legal expenses some communities have experienced after contracting with the firm. Belle hired Lauber Municipal Law in December 2023, and the article reported that the city has relied heavily on the firm in part because of its history of Sunshine Law violations.
The Missourian article also raised questions specific to Belle concerning access to meeting materials and public records, the city’s use of attorneys to review Sunshine Law requests, the censure of Alderwoman Rebecca Withouse and the significant increase in the city’s legal budget. Belle budgeted $3,288 for legal fees in fiscal year 2023-24, increased that amount to $15,000 the following year and budgeted $18,500 for the current fiscal year, according to the article. In light of those issues, The Advocate is asking members of the Belle Board of Aldermen and the mayor to address the following questions about the city’s relationship with Lauber Municipal Law, its Sunshine Law practices and the board’s oversight of legal services and spending.
I would appreciate the opportunity to interview each member of the board of aldermen individually, as well as Mayor Mitchell, regarding these issues. I understand this is a complex subject involving legal advice, city procedures, public records, finances and the responsibilities of elected officials. For that reason, I wanted to provide the questions in advance so each of you has an opportunity to conduct your own research and due diligence, review any records you believe are relevant, and fully consider the issues before we speak. My goal is to give everyone a fair opportunity to provide an informed response.
If you would prefer to answer some or all of these questions by email rather than through an interview, that is also acceptable. Additionally, these questions are not intended to limit what you may discuss. If there are facts, concerns, explanations or other issues regarding Lauber Municipal Law, Belle’s Sunshine Law practices, the city’s legal expenses or city operations that are not addressed below, please feel free to raise them. I welcome any additional information or perspective you believe residents should know.
1. Belle hired Lauber Municipal Law in December 2023. What specific problems or legal concerns led the city to hire the firm, and how would you evaluate whether those issues have been resolved since then?
2. The Missourian reported that Belle had previously been sued by the Missouri Attorney General over Sunshine Law violations. What specific policies, procedures or practices has the board changed since that settlement to prevent similar violations?
3. Rebecca Withouse told The Missourian that meeting packets are sometimes not provided to her until moments before meetings begin. What is the city’s current process for distributing meeting materials to aldermen, and how much time does the board believe members should have to review those materials before voting?
4. Mayor James Mitchell said Belle relies heavily on Lauber Municipal Law because of the city’s past Sunshine Law violations. How does the board determine whether that level of reliance is still necessary, and what would indicate that city officials have become capable of handling more routine matters independently?
5. Lauber attorney Nathan Nickolaus told The Missourian that smaller towns often lack Sunshine Law education and described rural cities as the firm’s “bread and butter.” Because Lauber is paid when Belle officials seek legal advice, what safeguards are in place to make sure the city is being educated to handle routine Sunshine Law matters independently rather than remaining dependent on the firm for recurring questions?
6. What formal Sunshine Law training has Lauber Municipal Law provided to Belle’s mayor, aldermen, city clerk and other employees since the firm was hired, and what subjects did that training cover?
7. If part of Lauber’s role is to educate Belle officials about the Sunshine Law, what explains the city’s continued reliance on the firm for records requests and recurring legal questions?
8. City Treasurer and Office Manager Charro Reasor told The Missourian that records requests that are not “something simple” are typically sent to the city attorney. What criteria are used to decide whether a request is simple or requires attorney review, who makes that decision, and what role does Lauber play in deciding what records are released?
9. How does Belle determine when attorney review costs connected to a Sunshine Law request can be charged to a requester, and what attorney-related costs, if any, have residents been charged?
10. What examples, if any, can the city provide of records requests that residents have narrowed, withdrawn or abandoned after receiving a cost estimate, and how does the city evaluate whether those costs may discourage access to public records?
11. The Missourian reported that Belle budgeted $3,288 for legal fees in 2023-24, then increased that amount to $15,000 and later $18,500. What services or legal needs drove that increase, and how does the board evaluate whether taxpayers are receiving appropriate value for that spending?
12. The article reported that Belle paid Lauber $78 for a 25-minute conversation with a reporter about a Sunshine Law request. What types of media or public-records questions does the city believe require attorney involvement, and what steps are taken to keep routine questions from generating unnecessary legal expenses?
13. What process does the board use to review Lauber Municipal Law’s invoices, and can you describe any instances in which board members questioned, challenged or sought clarification about whether particular work or charges were necessary?
14. The board censured Alderwoman Withouse and restricted how she could speak on behalf of the city. What specific conduct led to that action, what standards did the board apply and how does the city distinguish legitimate disciplinary action from restricting an elected official who raises concerns about transparency or city operations?
15. What experiences have aldermen had when questioning Lauber Municipal Law’s advice, legal bills or handling of Sunshine Law matters, and how does the board ensure members can raise those concerns without facing pressure or retaliation?
16. What protections or expectations are in place to ensure aldermen can publicly disagree with the city attorney, question legal advice or challenge city practices without being censured, excluded from information or otherwise penalized?
17. Nickolaus told the Missourian, “My client is the city as a corporate entity ... I don’t work for the citizens.” How does the board interpret that statement, and how does it reconcile the attorney’s duty to the municipal corporation with elected officials’ responsibility to Belle residents and the public’s open-government rights?
18. Given Belle’s history of Sunshine Law violations, what value would the board see in receiving Sunshine Law training from an attorney or organization unaffiliated with Lauber Municipal Law, and what concerns, if any, would the board have about doing so?
19. Under what circumstances would the board support an independent review of Belle’s legal spending, Sunshine Law practices and relationship with Lauber Municipal Law, and what areas would such a review need to examine?
20. What standards does the board use to evaluate whether Lauber Municipal Law remains the right firm to represent Belle, and what performance, cost, legal or trust-related issues could lead the city to consider different representation?
Thank you for taking the time to review these questions. I appreciate your willingness to address them and want to make sure each elected official has an opportunity to provide his or her perspective before The Advocate publishes any follow-up reporting on these issues.
Edward Gehlert, Reporter, Maries County Advocate.”
This is not the first set of questions that have been sent to city officials through the clerk’s office since Mitchell, Aldermen Jeanette Struemph and Vogt stopped responding to direct communication from The Advocate. The first series of questions was sent on June 25 and addressed growing concerns newspaper staff had with communication and transparency issues from City Hall after an interaction with Mitchell. The full email sent by The Advocate follows:
“Cindy,
Would you please forward the following questions to Mayor James Mitchell on behalf of The Maries County Advocate?
These questions stem from a recent conversation the mayor and I had regarding communication between City Hall and the newspaper. During that discussion, he expressed concerns that information gets “twisted around in the paper” and said that he was aware of several positive things happening in Belle but was not going to share them with the media.
Because those comments raise important questions about transparency, public communication and the relationship between City Hall and the local press, I want to provide the mayor with the opportunity to elaborate on his views in his own words. My goal is to accurately present his perspective and ensure readers have a complete understanding of the issues.
Written responses are perfectly acceptable and may be returned directly to me.
The questions are as follows:
1. During our conversation, you stated that information gets “twisted around in the paper.” Can you identify specific examples of information published by The Maries County Advocate that you believe was inaccurate and was never corrected?
2. If there are inaccuracies in reporting, why has the city not provided formal requests for corrections or clarifications?
3. Do you believe elected officials have a responsibility to communicate with the local newspaper even when they disagree with its coverage?
4. Has the City of Belle adopted any formal or informal policy regarding communication with The Maries County Advocate?
5. Are city officials discouraged from speaking with The Maries County Advocate? If so, why?
6. Why are important public notices, such as water-related announcements, often posted on social media without being sent to the local newspaper?
7. Does the city have a communication plan to ensure residents who do not use Facebook receive important information?
8. Would you support providing routine news releases or email notifications to local media regarding city matters?
9. Do you believe information about city projects, economic development efforts and community improvements should be proactively and transparently shared with the public?
10. During our conversation, you said there were positive things happening in Belle but that you were not going to share them. Why do you choose not to share that information with the public?
11. Do you believe trust between City Hall and the public has improved or declined during your tenure as mayor? Why?
12. How would you describe the current relationship between City Hall and The Maries County Advocate?
13. What would it take to improve communication between city officials and local media?
14. Do you believe transparency should include sharing information that may reflect positively on city government as well as information that may be controversial?
Thank you for your assistance in forwarding these questions. I appreciate the opportunity to hear the mayor’s perspective and include his responses in our reporting.
Respectfully,
Edward Gehlert
Maries County Advocate.
On Aug. 27, The Advocate followed up with Vogt and asked him if he would be able to elaborate on his accusations that the newspaper has been sending an “unending onslaught of unwarranted, insidious questions” to city officials.
Vogt declined to comment.